in the 'land of volcanoes' and quakes
A Japanese legislator expressed strong reservations about the wisdom of nuclear power in the "land of volcanoes" during a dinner with U.S. diplomats, according to a leaked State Department cable.
Lower House Diet Member Taro Kono in his October 2008 comments expressed concern about the issue of nuclear waste, pointing out that Japan had no permanent high-level waste storage, and thus no solution to the problem of storage. He cited Japan´s extensive seismic activity, and abundant groundwater, and questioned whether there really was a safe place to store nuclear waste in the "land of volcanoes."
Among problems faced in the current nuclear crisis is the overheating of spent fuel rods, which are contained on site because there is nowhere to dispose of them. One of the spent fuel pools contained particularly dangerous reprocessed fuel.
The cable, posted by Norway's Aftenposten newspaper from its cache of Wikileaks documents, follows. Below that is a set of cable links found on the Aftenposten web site.
REF: STATE 107836
Dokumentene
Internettstedet Wikileaks har fått tak i mer enn 250 000 dokumenter fra amerikanske ambassader og konsulater verden over.
Aftenposten har fått tilgang til alle dokumentene uten noen form for klausuler.
Dokumentene blir fortløpende vurdert som grunnlag for artikler etter de samme redaksjonelle kriterier og etiske regler som ellers i Aftenpostens journalistikk.
E-post til redaksjonen:
wikileaks@aftenposten.no
Internettstedet Wikileaks har fått tak i mer enn 250 000 dokumenter fra amerikanske ambassader og konsulater verden over.
Aftenposten har fått tilgang til alle dokumentene uten noen form for klausuler.
Dokumentene blir fortløpende vurdert som grunnlag for artikler etter de samme redaksjonelle kriterier og etiske regler som ellers i Aftenpostens journalistikk.
E-post til redaksjonen:
wikileaks@aftenposten.no
Classified By: Ambassador J. Thomas Schieffer; reasons 1.4 (b) and (d)
1. (C) Summary: Lower House Diet Member Taro Kono voiced his strong opposition to the nuclear industry in Japan, especially nuclear reprocessing, based on issues of cost, safety, and security during a dinner with a visiting staffdel, Energy Attache and Economic Officer October 21. Kono also criticized the Japanese bureaucracy and power companies for continuing an outdated nuclear energy strategy, suppressing development of alternative energy, and keeping information from Diet members and the public. He also expressed dissatisfaction with the current election campaign law. End Summary.
2. (C) Member of the House of Representatives Taro Kono spoke extensively on nuclear energy and nuclear fuel reprocessing during a dinner with a visiting staffdel, Energy Attache and Economic Officer October 21. Kono, a member of the Liberal Democratic Party first elected in 1996, is the son of Yohei Kono, a former President of the LDP who is currently the longest serving speaker of the House in post-war history. Taro Kono, who studied and worked in the United States and speaks excellent English, is a frequent embassy contact who has interests in agriculture, nuclear, and foreign policy issues. He is relatively young, and very outspoken, especially as a critic of the government´s nuclear policy. During this meeting, he voiced his strong opposition to the nuclear industry in Japan, especially nuclear fuel reprocessing, based on issues of cost, safety, and security. Kono claimed Japanese electric companies are hiding the costs and safety problems associated with nuclear energy, while successfully selling the idea of reprocessing to the Japanese public as "recycling uranium." He asserted that Japan´s reprocessing program had been conceived as part of a nuclear cycle designed to use reprocessed fuel in fast breeder reactors (FBR). However, these reactors have not been successfully deployed, and Japan´s prototype FBR at Monju is still off-line after an accident in 1995.
3. (C) Kono said following the accident at the Monju FBR, rather than cancel plans to conduct reprocessing, the electric companies developed the Mixed Oxide (MOX) fuel program. However, Kono criticized the MOX program as too expensive, noting it would be cheaper to just "buy a uranium mountain in Australia," or to make a deal to import uranium from other sources. Kono claimed the high costs of the reprocessing program were being passed to Japanese consumers in their power bills, and they were unaware of how much they paid for electricity relative to people in other countries. In describing the clout wielded by the electric companies, Kono claimed that a Japanese television station had planned a three part interview with him on nuclear issues, but had canceled after the first interview, because the electric companies threatened to withdraw their extensive sponsorship.
4. (C) In addition to the electric companies, Kono was also very critical of the Japanese ministries, particularly the Ministry of Economy, Trade, and Industry (METI). He claimed the ministries were trapped in their policies, as officials inherited policies from people more senior to them, which they could then not challenge. As an example, Kono noted that Japanese radiation standards for imported foods had been set following the Chernobyl incident, and had not changed since then, despite other nations having reduced their levels of allowable radiation.
5. (C) In a similar way, he alleged, METI was committed to advocating for nuclear energy development, despite the problems he attributed to it. Kono noted that while METI claimed to support alternative energy, it in actuality provides little support. He claimed that METI in the past had orchestrated the defeat of legislation that supported alternatives energy development, and instead secured the passage of the Renewables Portfolio Standard (RPS) act. This act simply requires power companies to purchase a very small amount of their electricity from alternative sources. Kono also criticized the government´s handling of subsidies to alternative energy projects, noting that the subsidies were of such short duration that the projects have difficulty finding investors because of the risk and uncertainty involved. As a more specific example of Japan neglecting alternative energy sources, Kono noted there was abundant wind power available in Hokkaido that went undeveloped because the electricity company claimed it did not have sufficient grid capacity. Kono noted there was in fact an unused connection between the Hokkaido grid and the Honshu grid that the companies keep in reserve for unspecified emergencies. He wanted to know why they could not just link the grids and thus gain the ability to add in more wind power.
6. (C) He also accused METI of covering up nuclear accidents, and obscuring the true costs and problems associated with the nuclear industry. He claimed MPs have a difficult time hearing the whole of the U.S. message on nuclear energy because METI picks and chooses those portions of the message that it likes. Only information in agreement with METI policies is passed through to the MPs. Elaborating on his frustrations with the ministries, Kono noted that the Diet committee staffs are made up of professional bureaucrats, and are often headed by detailees from the ministries. He said he had no authority to hire or fire committee staff, and that any inquiries he made to them quickly found their way back to the ministries.
7. (C) Kono also raised the issue of nuclear waste, commenting that Japan had no permanent high-level waste storage, and thus no solution to the problem of storage. He cited Japan´s extensive seismic activity, and abundant groundwater, and questioned if there really was a safe place to store nuclear waste in the "land of volcanoes." He noted that Rokkasho was only intended as a temporary holding site for high-level waste. The Rokkasho local government, he said, had only agreed to store waste temporarily contingent on its eventual reprocessing. Kono said that in this regard, the US was better off that Japan because of the Yucca mountain facility. He was somewhat surprised to hear about opposition to that project, and the fact that Yucca had not yet begun storing waste.
8. (C) In describing how he would deal with Japan´s future energy needs, Kono claimed Japan needed to devise a real energy strategy. He said while he believed Japan eventually would have to move to 100% renewable energy, in the meantime he advocated replacing energy produced by nuclear plants ready for decommissioning with an equal amount of energy from plants using liquid natural gas. To this he would add new renewable energy sources.
9. (C) Kono also made a few side remarks concerning the Japanese election process. He expressed dissatisfaction with the current election campaign law, which he called outdated. He noted, for example, that during the official campaign period he was not allowed to actively campaign on the Internet. He said he could print flyers during this time, but only a limited number, which had to be picked up by constituents at his campaign office. So, to get around these and other limitations, MPs had to campaign before the official campaign period began. Given the current uncertainty on a date for elections, he noted in a humorous manner that if the government delayed elections long enough, he and the other MPs would go broke. SCHIEFFER
UNCLAS TOKYO 003263SIPDISSIPDISE...JA SUBJECT: JAPAN: NUCLEAR POWER: EARTHQUAKE CAUSES...at Kashiwazki-Kariwa Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) and...safety checks. Reports by Tokyo Electric Power Company...Post´s contact at Japan´s Nuclear and Industrial Safety...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article4062825.ece UNCLAS TOKYO 003296 SIPDIS SIPDIS...TRGY SUBJECT: JAPAN: NUCLEAR POWER: ADDITIONAL MISHAPS...KASHIWAZAKI-KARIWA REF: TOKYO 03263 1) SUMMARY: On July 17, Tokyo Electric Power Company...Kashiwazaki-Kariwa Nuclear Power Plant in Niigata...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article4062820.ece 27.10.2008: MP CRITICIZES JAPANESE NUCLEAR PLANS 18.mar.2011
...her: C O N F I D E N T I A L TOKYO 002993 SIPDIS DEPT FOR EAP...SUBJECT: MP CRITICIZES JAPANESE NUCLEAR PLANS REF: STATE 107836 Classified...his strong opposition to the nuclear industry in Japan, especially nuclear reprocessing, based on issues...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article4064035.ece4.
23/08/2007: Official Discusses Japan´s "Confused" Political Situation, East China Sea and More 16.mar.2011
...information on the impact of the earthquake on the nuclear power plant, see Tokyo 03296 and Tokyo 03263. (EST: Ayanna Hobbs)19...TEPCO Officials Brief Embassy on Kashiwazaki-Kariwa Nuclear Plant Damage...
26/07/2007: The Japan Economic Scope 16.mar.2011
...setter, please see Tokyo 3399. David DiGiovanna...Kashiwazaki-Kariwa nuclear plants owned by Tokyo Electric Power Co. Some...Kashiwazaki-Kariwa nuclear plant, following the...to a press release by Tokyo Electric Power Company...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article4062815.ece 14.08.2007: CLIMATE CHANGE: EMISSION IMPOSSIBLE: NPP SHUTDOWN EXACERBATES JAPAN´S KYOTO TARGET BIND 18.mar.2011
...Les saken her: UNCLAS TOKYO 003739 SIPDIS SIPDIS STATE...since the Plan assumes nuclear power plants (NPPs...appear overly optimistic. Nuclear power plants provide about...earthquake. In FY 2003, when Tokyo Electric Power was forced...earthquake on Japan´s nuclear power industry is as...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article4064034.ece ...E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 02 TOKYO 003679 SIPDIS SIPDIS OSD FOR...developments in China in such areas as TOKYO 00003679 002 OF 002 human rights...of his interest in Japan´s nuclear energy program, Minister Koike...of the Kashiwazaki-Kariwa nuclear plant had not been damaged in...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article4062828.ece ...return for 3.63 million yen in TOKYO 00005603 002 OF 010 bribes Nikkei...Constitutional review imperative Tokyo Shimbun: New students at nursing...hides 8 active faults near Shiga nuclear power plant 2) EDITORIALS Asahi...successful Aegis missile test Tokyo Shimbun: (1) Moriya rearrested...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article3972794.ece 2.12.2008: BILATERAL RELATIONSHIPS WITH SWITZERLAND AND THE PRINCIPALITY OF LIECHTENSTEIN 10.jan.2011
...weeks the Swiss position in the Iran-Nuclear dispute is completely clear. There is...explore a diplomatic dialogue on the Iranian nuclear proliferation issue, perhaps we could...which held its last negotiating round in Tokyo in October 2008 and is intended to increase...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article3980221.ece S E C R E T TOKYO 000011 SIPDIS STATE FOR ISN/RA, ISN/CPI, EAP/J, SCA/CEN E...was unfamiliar with the companies involved, but would work with METIs nuclear energy division, which should already have the required corporate contacts...
http://www.aftenposten.no/spesial/wikileaksdokumenter/article3988310.ece 
No comments:
Post a Comment